| Name [last, first, grade] | School | Time | Date | Type |
| Bonafede, Dan (8) | Churchville Chili | 11:57 | 10-25-2011 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Metcalfe, Keegan (8) | Churchville Chili | 11:59 | 10-19-2016 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Bailey, Caleb (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:00 | 10-19-2016 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Giglia, Ryan (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:20 | 10-16-2019 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Dick, Ryan (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:27 | 10-19-2016 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Colucci, Nick (7) | Churchville Chili | 12:28 | 10-25-2011 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Giglia, Ryan (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:28 | 10-22-2019 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Taylor, Colin (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:30 | 10-20-2015 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Ruhland, Matt (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:31 | 10-25-2011 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Bathgate, Dawson (8) | East Rochester | 12:33 | 10-18-2011 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Colucci, Nick (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:33 | 10-16-2012 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Raines, Coy (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:37 | 10-22-2019 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Hobson, Bryce (8) | Batavia | 12:39 | 10-21-2008 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Esposito, Caleb (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:41 | 10-12-2023 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Caballero, Aaron (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:42 | 10-15-2018 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Laird, Jon (8) | Batavia | 12:48 | 10-16-2007 | League Meet Modified Race |
| LeFrois, Alan Michael (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:49 | 10-19-2016 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Roth, Max (8) | Canandaigua | 12:54 | 10-23-2012 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Loce, Matthew (8) | Willink | 12:54 | 10-21-2008 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Iwasko, Aidan (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:54 | 10-20-2015 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Cayward, Colton (8) | Canandaigua | 12:59 | 10-23-2012 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Raines, Coy (8) | Churchville Chili | 12:59 | 10-16-2019 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Thompson, Robert (7) | Dake | 13:03 | 10-16-2012 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Giglia, Ryan (7) | Churchville Chili | 13:10 | 10-15-2018 | League Meet Modified Race |
| Johnson, Keith (7) | Willink | 13:11 | 10-21-2008 | League Meet Modified Race |